The Shanghai Intellectual Property Court has ordered TJ Innova Engineering & Technology Co., a Shanghai automotive engineering company, to pay Dassault Systèmes RMB 15.05 million for using CATIA without a license. It was the highest award the court had made since it was founded in late 2014.
At a glance
- Court: Shanghai Intellectual Property Court (first instance)
- Judgment: mid-2018, reported by China Daily on 9 August 2018
- Parties: Dassault Systèmes v. TJ Innova Engineering & Technology Co.
- Software: CATIA V5 series
- Outcome: an order to stop the infringement and RMB 15.05 million in economic losses and reasonable costs
The evidence
According to China Daily, the company had advertised on job sites for technicians skilled in CATIA. Before the trial Dassault Systèmes applied for evidence preservation, and the court used it to establish how many copies the company had installed without permission.
Above the statutory ceiling
The court found that Dassault Systèmes’ losses clearly exceeded the RMB 500,000 ceiling for statutory damages that applied at the time. It set damages above that ceiling, weighing the number of unlicensed copies, the price of CATIA, how long the software had been used and the company’s bad faith.
Why this decision matters
- Losses, not ceilings, decide the award. The court set damages above the statutory maximum because the license value showed a far larger loss.
- Bad faith raises the bill. The duration of the use and the company’s intent were part of the calculation.
- Evidence preservation is the key step. The copy count came from a court-ordered search before trial.
Source: China Daily, 9 August 2018; Sina News, 8 October 2018.
Received a notice from ITCA? See how to verify and resolve it.