Three Turkish criminal courts have found copyright offences established against businesses that used Alphacam and Tekla Structures without a license. In each case the defendant raised a different defense, and in each case the court rejected it on the technical evidence. The proceedings were pursued by ITCA’s legal team in Turkey on behalf of Planit Software (Alphacam) and Trimble (Tekla Structures).

TRY 30,400judicial fine in each case
3courts, three rejected defenses
5 yearsprobation period
TRY 55,000attorney fee to the rights holder

At a glance

  • Courts: Sakarya, İnegöl and Manisa 3rd Criminal Courts of First Instance
  • Judgments: 20 November 2025 (Sakarya), 5 February 2026 (Manisa) and 17 February 2026 (İnegöl)
  • Offence: Article 71/1 of Law No. 5846 on Intellectual and Artistic Works, punishable by one to five years’ imprisonment or a judicial fine
  • Outcome in each case: a judicial fine of TRY 30,400, with the pronouncement of the judgment deferred for a five-year probation period
  • Also ordered: an attorney’s fee of TRY 55,000 to the rights holder, plus court costs

Sakarya: installed, but “never used”

A court-appointed expert found an unlicensed installation of Alphacam on a computer at a design business. The defendant admitted installing the software but said it had never been used for business.

The examination found 254 project files associated with Alphacam, and the court gave no credit to the defendant’s account. It also stressed that the person managing a business is responsible for making sure the software on its computers is licensed, and that earning money from the software is not an element of the offence: copying it is enough.

İnegöl: “installed by a customer”

A court-ordered inspection at a furniture manufacturer found an unlicensed copy of Alphacam Router Ultimate on a production computer. The defendant said a customer had installed it, that the company never used it and that it was not compatible with the company’s CNC machinery.

A court-appointed expert established that the unlicensed copy was installed and that files had been created with it. The court rejected the explanation and found that the software had been used in the company’s production.

Manisa: the “personal laptop” defense

A criminal search at an architecture and engineering office found Tekla Structures on a laptop. The defendant said the laptop was his own, that he was only visiting the office and that the software was not used commercially.

The court looked at the three-dimensional project files created with Tekla Structures, the absence of any license and the defendant’s profession, and rejected the personal-use defense.

What “deferred pronouncement” means

In all three cases the court found the offence established and set the fine, then deferred the pronouncement of the judgment under Article 231 of the Turkish Code of Criminal Procedure. If the defendant commits no new intentional offence during the five-year probation period, the case is dismissed. If they do, the court announces the judgment.

Why these decisions matter

  • Defenses must be backed by evidence. Non-use, installation by someone else and personal use were each tested against the technical findings, not accepted on the defendant’s word.
  • Technical evidence decides the case. Project files, installation records and the link to the defendant’s professional work were decisive in all three judgments.
  • Civil and criminal routes both work. Two cases began with court-ordered civil evidence inspections; the third began with a criminal search.
  • Managers carry the responsibility. The Sakarya court held the person running the business responsible for the licensing of its computers.

Received a notice from ITCA? See how to verify and resolve it.