A Louisiana auto parts distributor and its owner have been sentenced in US federal court for building and selling counterfeit Mercedes-Benz diagnostic units loaded with unlicensed copies of the carmaker’s Star Diagnostic System software. The case involved more than 800 infringing copies valued at over US$17 million, and the company must help Mercedes-Benz identify every customer that received the software.
At a glance
- Court: US District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana, Judge Nannette Jolivette Brown
- Guilty pleas: announced by the US Department of Justice on 10 September 2015
- Sentencing: announced on 14 January 2016
- Defendants: The Brinson Company, an aftermarket auto parts distributor in Harahan, Louisiana, and its owner, Rainer Wittich
- Charges: criminal copyright infringement; conspiracy to commit criminal copyright infringement and to violate the Digital Millennium Copyright Act
- Sentences: the owner, five years’ probation and a US$3,000 fine; the company, five years’ probation, forfeiture of US$150,000 and an order to help Daimler AG compile a list of every customer that received the infringing devices or software
Counterfeit diagnostic units
The Mercedes-Benz Star Diagnostic System (SDS) is a portable computer with proprietary Mercedes-Benz diagnostic software that requires a license key. A genuine unit sold for up to US$22,000, and owners paid Mercedes-Benz several thousand dollars a year for software updates.
From about 2001, the company and two other companies developed, built and sold non-authentic SDS units. The company admitted that it obtained the SDS software and updates without authorization, modified and copied the software and installed it on laptops that served as the units. It sold about 725 devices, at up to US$11,000 each; one co-conspirator sold at least 95 more.
“Go underground and off the radar”
By June 2010 at the latest, the company was buying software, updates and patches for the units from an individual in the United Kingdom. After Mercedes-Benz told that individual his conduct was illegal, the company and its co-conspirators discussed plans to have him “go underground and off the radar” while continuing to support the units.
The customers are next
Under its plea agreement and sentence, the company must help Mercedes-Benz and its parent, Daimler AG, compile a list of all customers to whom it sold, distributed, donated or otherwise provided the infringing software. The case was investigated by the Cyber Task Force of the FBI’s New Orleans Division.
The two other business owners in the scheme were sentenced a few months later (read the case).
Why this case matters
- Owners are personally liable. The company’s owner pleaded guilty and was sentenced alongside his company.
- Warnings are evidence. Plans to help a supplier “go underground” after a warning from the rights holder became part of the case.
- Buyers can be traced. The court ordered the seller to hand the rights holder a list of everyone who received the software.
- Industrial and diagnostic software is protected like any other software. Copying it and bypassing its license key is a federal crime in the United States.
Source: US Department of Justice, guilty plea (10 September 2015) and sentencing (14 January 2016); The Detroit News, 10 September 2015.
Received a notice from ITCA? See how to verify and resolve it.