The Beijing Intellectual Property Court has ordered an automotive engineering company to pay Dassault Systèmes RMB 20 million for making 103 unlicensed copies of CATIA. The court treated the company’s use of virtual desktops during the court-ordered search as obstruction and estimated the number of copies from a sample of its computers.
At a glance
- Court: Beijing Intellectual Property Court (first instance)
- Judgment: announced by the court on 24 April 2023
- Parties: Dassault Systèmes v. IAT Automobile Technology Co., Ltd.
- Software: CATIA V5R18, V5R19, V5-6 and V5-6R2016
- Outcome: RMB 20 million in damages plus RMB 80,500 in reasonable expenses; delete the unlicensed copies and destroy the media holding them
- Status: the judgment was under appeal when last reported
Sampling the evidence
At Dassault Systèmes’ request, the court ordered an evidence preservation at the company’s premises. With both parties’ agreement it examined a random sample of 54 of the 343 office computers. On 42 of the sampled computers virtual desktop software was running, which the court treated as obstructing the evidence preservation.
From the sample the court estimated 146 copies in total. It deducted 43 licensed copies the company may have installed at its Beijing office and found 103 unlicensed copies.
The judgment
The court found that the company’s commercial use of the software without authorization infringed Dassault Systèmes’ right of reproduction. It awarded the full RMB 20 million Dassault Systèmes claimed for its economic losses, plus RMB 80,500 in reasonable expenses, and ordered the company to delete the unlicensed copies and destroy the media containing them.
Why this decision matters
- Courts extrapolate. When a full count is not possible, a court can estimate the number of copies from a sample.
- Hiding the evidence counts against you. Running virtual desktops during a court search was treated as obstruction.
- Damages track the license value. At about RMB 194,000 per copy, the award reflects what licenses for engineering software actually cost.
Source: Beijing Intellectual Property Court, as reported by China IP Law Update (April 2023) and AllBright Law Offices (May 2023).
Received a notice from ITCA? See how to verify and resolve it.